Butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA, E320) and butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT, E321) are synthetic phenolic antioxidants widely used in foods, beverages, cosmetics, and pharmaceuticals to retard lipid oxidation.
Despite their efficacy and low cost, both compounds have faced regulatory scrutiny due to toxicological concerns, including possible carcinogenicity (BHA) and endocrine-disrupting potential (BHT).
The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) has set low acceptable daily intakes (BHA: 1 mg/kg bw/day; BHT: 0.25 mg/kg bw/day). In cosmetics, the EU Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS) restricts BHT to ≤0.001% in mouthwash and ≤0.1% in leave-on/rinse-off products.
The US FDA still permits both at ≤0.02% of fat content in food, while Codex Alimentarius allows their use in defined categories. Growing consumer preference for “clean-label” and plant-based preservatives has accelerated the shift toward natural antioxidants such as tocopherols, rosemary extract, and polyphenols.
Regulatory Landscape
| Region / Authority | Current Status | Key Restrictions | Implications for R&D |
| United States (FDA) | Permitted under 21 CFR §172.110 (BHA) and §172.115 (BHT) | Max 0.02% of fat/oil content in foods; labeling required. Both are GRAS; BHT also permitted in packaging waxes. | Still usable in US formulations, but limited to specific fat-containing foods; consumer demand shifting to natural antioxidants. |
| European Union (EFSA/EC) | Authorized as E320 (BHA) and E321 (BHT) in food additives | BHA: ADI = 1 mg/kg bw/day (EFSA, 2011). BHT: ADI = 0.25 mg/kg bw/day (EFSA, 2012). Cosmetic limits: ≤0.001% in mouthwash; ≤0.1% in leave-on/rinse-off. | Narrow authorized uses; must comply with additive limits. Cosmetics R&D must reformulate or replace with tocopherols/rosemary extract for leave-on systems. |
| Codex Alimentarius (GSFA) | Listed as INS 320 (BHA) and 321 (BHT) | Max levels: 100–200 mg/kg in fats, oils, chewing gum, and selected foods. | Allowed in many Codex-aligned countries, but subject to category-specific maximums. Verify country adoption before commercialization. |
| Canada (Health Canada) | Permitted | Follows Codex-like limits; case-by-case evaluation in cosmetics. | Food approvals aligned with Codex; cosmetics may require EU-aligned restrictions for exports. |
| Pharma (USP–NF, Ph.Eur.) | Listed as excipients | Max 0.02% in oil phase of formulations; used in oral and topical dosage forms. | Still widely accepted in pharma, but consumer-facing nutraceuticals moving toward tocopherols. |
| Packaging (FDA / REACH, EU) | Permitted in plastics | FDA: ≤0.01% by weight of polymer (21 CFR §178.2010). REACH: BHT flagged as potential endocrine disruptor (under review). | Stable for polymer stabilization, but REACH review may lead to restrictions; explore tocopherols or ascorbyl palmitate for food-contact polymers. |
Why Replace BHA and BHT
- Regulatory pressure: Tight ADI limits, cosmetic restrictions, and labeling obligations.
- Toxicological concerns: Carcinogenic potential (BHA), endocrine activity (BHT).
- Consumer perception: Preference for plant-derived, minimally processed ingredients.
- Functional rationale: Natural antioxidants deliver comparable stabilization (0.05–0.3%), often with synergistic effects when blended.
Manufacturers and Alternatives
1. Kemin Industries (USA)
Kemin offers NaturFORT and FORTIUM antioxidants, based on rosemary extract (20–40% carnosic acid) and mixed tocopherols (>70% d-α, γ, δ).
These are oil-dispersible, thermally stable up to 180 °C, and FDA GRAS and EFSA-approved. They support oxidative stability in frying oils, bakery fats, and cosmetics.
2. Naturex/Givaudan (France/Global)
Naturex (now part of Givaudan) supplies XtraBlend RN and XtraBlend XP, antioxidant systems combining rosemary extract (carnosol, carnosic acid) with acerola cherry (ascorbic acid) or green tea polyphenols.
These are water- and oil-dispersible, stable at pH 3–7, and effective in meat, sauces, and emulsions. They are listed in EU food additive regulations as E392 (rosemary extract) and comply with FDA GRAS notices. Naturex provides custom synergistic blends for clean-label reformulations.
3. Camlin Fine Sciences (India/Global)
Camlin offers Xtendra BHT replacements based on green tea catechins, rosemary, and mixed tocopherols. Purity ranges: tocopherols ≥50% (soy/canola derived, non-GMO), catechins ≥40%.
Products are oil-soluble, stable up to 200 °C, and show synergism with ascorbyl palmitate. Camlin supplies to food, feed, and cosmetics markets under global approvals (FDA GRAS, EFSA E306–E309 tocopherols). Technical R&D support includes peroxide value and Rancimat testing.
4. Vitablend (Barentz Group, Netherlands)
Vitablend produces custom antioxidant premixes using tocopherols, rosemary, ascorbyl palmitate, and natural chelators. Their liquid and powder systems are tailored to fats, infant nutrition, and dietary supplements.
Tocopherol concentrates (≥70%) are stable at neutral pH and up to 160 °C, with Codex and EFSA approval as E306–E309. Vitablend offers microencapsulation for improved solubility in aqueous systems. Global regulatory dossiers are available to support submissions.
5. FLAVEX Naturextrakte GmbH (Germany)
FLAVEX specializes in supercritical CO₂ extracts, including rosemary extract standardized to 20–25% carnosic acid. These are solvent-free, oil-dispersible, stable up to 180 °C, and EFSA-approved (E392).
They are used in high-fat matrices such as oils, dressings, and cosmetic creams. FLAVEX also provides sage and oregano extracts with synergistic antioxidative activity. The company supplies technical dossiers for REACH and EFSA compliance.
Formulation Considerations
- Dosage: 0.05–0.3% depending on fat load and matrix.
- Compatibility: Tocopherols synergize with ascorbyl palmitate; rosemary effective in oils; acerola better in low-pH aqueous matrices.
- Processing stability: Tocopherols degrade >180 °C; rosemary withstands up to 200 °C; polyphenols sensitive to alkaline pH.
- Packaging: Use oxygen-impermeable systems (e.g., PET/EVOH multilayers) to maximize antioxidant effect.
Conclusion
The replacement of BHA and BHT is being driven by regulatory restrictions, toxicological concerns, and consumer demand for plant-derived preservatives.
Natural antioxidants such as rosemary extract, tocopherols, and polyphenols offer technically viable alternatives across food, beverage, cosmetic, and pharmaceutical applications. These solutions are commercially scalable, regulatorily approved, and aligned with clean-label trends.
Looking to replace BHA and BHT in your formulations? Fill out the form below to get tailored supplier options, technical specs, and regulatory guidance for your R&D projects.